Home
Biography
Book
Book Signings
Columns
Interviews
Press
Pictures
GuestBook

Introducing her book
"I am my father's daughter"



Home | Biography | Book | Press | Pictures | GuestBook

THE PROBLEM WITH HEALTH-CARE REFORM

Written by Maria Elena Salinas   
December 7, 2009
 

I've been trying to figure out what the problem is with health-care reform. Clearly, if the answer was easy, we wouldn't have World War 3 going on in Congress over this, and the American people wouldn't be totally confused. But I have come up with a few theories that might explain why it is so difficult to deal with one of the most pressing issues of our time in the U.S.

First, there are the obvious problems. In Congress, it's politicking at its worst. Republicans have been all over the proposed health-care reform bill. Even though they have not presented a clear alternative to the current bill, they not only are criticizing the public option and the high cost of the health overhaul, but actually leading people to believe that they will lose their current health insurance and telling senior citizens that Democrats want them to die sooner. They warn of socialized medicine, calling the new proposals un-American. Democrats call it scare tactics. But Democrats have not done such a great job of explaining the bill to the average person and of countering Republican attacks, which leads me to the next obvious problem with health-care reform: People don't understand it.

That explains why the country is so divided on this issue. President Barack Obama and Democratic members of Congress have said over and over again that no one who currently has health insurance will lose it and that it will help cut costs, but people just don't believe it. Doubts could be dispelled if only people took the time to personally analyze the proposals. But who has the time to go over 2,000 pages, and even if they did, would they be able to understand it?

Adding to the confusion, you have advocacy groups jamming the airwaves for and against it. A record $170 million has already been spent by groups on all sides of the health-care debate, according to the Campaign Media Analysis Group, with a new million-dollar campaign being launched just to persuade five key Senate Democrats to oppose it.

Then there is the very unfortunate side of all this. The majority of Americans don't see the urgency of overhauling health care in this country because they already have insurance. It seems like most people simply don't care about the 30 million people who don't have access to health insurance. There actually are about 47 million, but because most of those are undocumented and would not qualify for health-care benefits under the proposed plan, they don't seem to count. That in itself is regrettable, because it is those who don't have insurance who end up going to the emergency room when they are in an advanced stage of illness and end up bringing the cost of treatment even higher, not to mention the human cost.

Most polls in the past six months have shown a lack of support among the American people for health-care reform. The latest Rasmussen poll showed only 38 percent support, and a Gallup poll showed 35 percent support. But for the Latino community, surprisingly, health-care reform has become a top priority -- more important than the economy, the war in Afghanistan and even immigration.

A new survey conducted by impreMedia, Latino Decisions and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Center for Health Policy at the University of New Mexico, among 1,000 Hispanic registered voters in 21 states, shows that Latino concerns go beyond their own personal needs. Seventy-five percent of those questioned had insurance but still believed reform is urgent.

The results of the survey show that Latinos care about their community as a whole when it comes to health-care reform. When asked about the reasons for their support, 30 percent pointed out the number of uninsured, and 22 percent said health care needs to be more affordable. Only 5 percent of Latino voters mentioned that they themselves or a family member was uninsured.

Senate Democrats have an uphill battle. Majority Leader Harry Reid says he wants to have a bill approved by the end of the year, even if it means working through Christmas Day. Not easy, when people are focused on the holiday season and opponents are focused on defeating the bill. It would be great if in the spirit of the holiday season they understood that while money can't buy health, it can certainly buy health care.

***

(Maria Elena Salinas is the author of “I AM MY FATHER'S DAUGHTER: LIVING A LIFE WITHOUT SECRETS.” Reach her at www .mariaesalinas.com)

© 2009 by Maria Elena Salinas

Distributed by King Features Syndicate